Ahh, that clears it up. I misunderstood you.
Equal voting tights for everyone
- 0 Posts
- 14 Comments
Just because it explains an experience, doesn’t mean it’s statistically true in a deep way. I would tend to agree that the Dunning Kruger effect is a nice logical story, a shorthand if you will. I would really be careful about placing undue confidence in neat little explanations of a stupefyingly complex word, especially when it concerns yet incomprehensible structures like the brain.

Plot with green points is Dunning Kruger data. It’s hardly correlated.
The Dunning Kruger-effect is a shaky concept. Recent studies seem to have disproved it in some ways.
Fresh knowledge is not to be underestimated.
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•Trump says the US is officially renaming AI to ‘super intelligence’English
4·2 months agoThe already bullshit concept of an “AI” super intelligence had a definition. This renaming is completely nonsensical and nullifies the original meaning.
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•Trump says the US is officially renaming AI to ‘super intelligence’English
2·2 months agoPirating is ethical, spotify is not!
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•AI staff 'genuinely frightened' for humanity's future, ex-Anthropic researcher tells BBCEnglish
2·2 months agoSame, I am worried about humans using ANNs to kill people. Current society is a gigantic apparatus that is constantly shifting shuffling responsibility around. LMMs only accelerate the problem.
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•We Tracked a Shipment of Rare Books. It Ended at an Amazon AI Training FacilityEnglish
1·3 months agoNo, even this is a very bad idea. Ideally, no books are destroyed. A close relative of mine works as an archivist. They have tons of examples of how digitising and then destroying can create extra burdens. The data on hard drives or flash devices is too fragile.
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•We Tracked a Shipment of Rare Books. It Ended at an Amazon AI Training FacilityEnglish
1·3 months agoI know that in disciplines such as math there are very often have books with less than 50 copies in circulation. The LLM companies buy maybe 2 of a given book which are subsequently destroyed with no backup data. You’re now at 48 in circulation, that is a significant reduction. Rinse and repeat a couple of million times and this starts to have a major influence on knowledge.
What’s perverse about it is that the data from the books is stored extremely badly within the models. So not only are you destroying sources, you are also necessarily falsifying them.
distal@lemmy.mlto
Technology@lemmy.world•We Tracked a Shipment of Rare Books. It Ended at an Amazon AI Training FacilityEnglish
2·3 months agoPretty sure information that is hard to come by on the internet includes rare books.

I’ll correct myself, the data is simulated and I skipped the word. You are completely right to remind me of this. But there are a few important considerations here.
Wiki quote: “The initial study by David Dunning and Justin Kruger examined the performance and self-assessment of undergraduate students in inductive, deductive, and abductive logical reasoning; English grammar; and appreciation of humor.”
Second of all, for this I have consulted the study itself, according to my cursory read the sample size of the study seems to be below 100. I’ll let that speak for itself.
A new study working with more data, that doesn’t just present generalised skill shows that, just like in the simulated data, it is still a blob following a normal distribution in terms of density. The simulated data was meant to show how misleading inferences can be made with noisy results.